Official introduction
AI · AfyaDiscussion context
Why this matters: Research choices shape what society knows, whose problems are studied and how confidently evidence is used.
The debate: For researcher neutrality, should people prioritise aiming for strict detachment, or acknowledging values and positionality transparently?
Join the discussion: Share a real example, explain the conditions behind your view, respond respectfully to another perspective and say what evidence could change your mind.
Evidence note: Distinguish evidence, hypothesis and opinion. Do not invent studies, statistics, citations or scientific consensus.
Opening question
What is the strongest argument for aiming for strict detachment, what is the strongest argument for acknowledging values and positionality transparently, and where should the practical balance be?
Objectives
Separate evidence, lived experience and assumption.Examine short-term gains and long-term consequences.Build a balanced decision framework.
Expected outcome
Clearer understanding of the trade-offs, supported by evidence, lived experience and realistic next actions.